Review – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey

15 Dec

THE HOBBIT: AN UNEXPECTED JOURNEY

(Full disclosure: I did not see An Unexpected Journey at 48fps. A movie ticket is a vote, and I refuse to vote for this process.)

Say this for Peter Jackson’s adaptation of The Hobbit: it makes no attempt to tonally match the earlier, darker Lord of the Rings series. After all, stakes don’t get much higher than the possible end of the known world – lighter quests deserve lighter treatment. J. R. R. Tolkien understood this; it’s why Lord of the Rings reads like mythology while The Hobbit reads like a children’s story. Likewise, An Unexpected Journey possesses a lightheartedness the other films don’t. Dwarves laugh and sing, trolls argue in comedic fashion, two characters try to outsmart each other with riddles, etc.

The problems with An Unexpected Journey, then, mostly stem from what just about everybody predicted they would: its length. There is simply not enough material in Tolkien’s 270-page novel, a simple story about well-to-do homebody Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman) accompanying thirteen dwarves on a quest to reclaim their home and gold from a dragon named Smaug, to justify three three-hour films. Jackson tries to pad out the story whenever he gets the chance, sometimes expanding on events only hinted at in the book (a certain evil force looms threateningly in the south), sometimes adding entirely new characters and subplots (a grudge between lead dwarf Richard Armitage and an orc leader), and other times finding various excuses to include characters from Lord of the Rings (a frame story including Elijah Wood and Ian Holm). Unfortunately, this stretching of the plot often makes the film feel unfocused and minor, more like a television miniseries than a big-budget movie.

Perhaps most problematic is the introduction of wizard Radagast, a minor character in Tolkien’s universe who should probably remain that way. Essentially the Jar Jar Binks of An Unexpected Journey, he has a bird’s nest under his hat, poop running down the side of his face, and a sled drawn by rabbits. Even taking into account the more bouyant tone, any scene featuring Radagast feels cartoonish and out of place. Another misstep is an odd Council of Elrond-esque scene in Rivendell consisting entirely of characters from Lord of the Rings. It gives the audience no new information and amounts to little more than winking references to the earlier films.

In spite of its myriad flaws, An Unexpected Journey also has much to recommend it. Middle-Earth looks as inviting as ever, Martin Freeman and Ian McKellen give excellent performances, and Andy Serkis’ reappearance as Gollum sets the stage for the film’s best and most entertaining sequence. Indeed, these elements work so well that it’s difficult not to be somewhat disappointed with the muddled end result. Here’s my idea: when the time comes in two years for the DVD boxset, Jackson should make a new cut – not adding new footage as he did for Lord for the Rings, but removing any and all of the excess from The Hobbit. I am convinced that a great adventure movie lies somewhere amid all the fluff.

Grade: B

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: